Replacing an Asphalt Shingle

Shingles get damaged. Maybe a falling tree limb leaves a puncture, or wind rips a corner, or a careless teenager sneaking a cigarette on his parents’ porch roof tears a shingle. Replacement isn’t hard, but it’s not exactly straightforward, either.

First, try to pick a temperate day to replace asphalt shingles. If it’s too hot, you’ll damage the roof just by being on it, never mind burn your hands on the hot shingles. If it’s too cold, the shingles won’t be flexible. They’ll be hard to work with and likely to break when you try to bend them. Temperatures in the 60s are ideal. If it’s going to be a hot summer day, work very early in the morning. If it’s winter, wait until spring if you can. If you can’t, pick a sunny afternoon and work gently.

Shingles usually are secured by a row of three or four nails placed just underneath where the upper shingle laps. These nails penetrate that shingle, and the top edge of the shingle below it, which means you have to loosen two courses of shingles above the one you’re replacing for access. The underside of the bottom edges of shingles have tabs of asphalt applied at the factory. After installation, the sun heats and melts these tabs, gluing the bottom edge of each shingle to the one below—this keeps wind from getting under shingles and lifting them off the roof. Part of replacing a shingle is loosening these tabs and replacing them with asphalt cement.

Safe practices dictate that you be properly secured with a fall-arrest harness, or that you set up scaffolding along the edge of the roof in case of a fall. I chose to forego the usual safety equipment for this job, though, because the roof I’m working on is a very shallow, 3-in-12 pitch, one story above the ground. Under normal circumstances, though, take the time to protect yourself and your workers.

Bonus feature: Watch video of the shingle-replacement process.

Click the PDF button below for complete step-by-step photos and advice.

Fine Homebuilding Recommended Products

Flashing Boot Repair

Prolonged exposure to the sun and weather can compromise the rubber gasket on standard vent flashing. Use this to quickly and permanently fix failed seals or to help protect the gasket in new-construction applications.

Buy at Amazon

Fall Protection

With a 50-ft safety line and a hinged, reusable anchor, this complete safety harness kit allows you to easily protect yourself while working comfortably and efficiently.

Buy at Amazon

Roofing Gun

This lightweight, pneumatic roofing nailer is capable of driving ¾-in to 1¾-in coil roofing nails and has a depth adjustment wheel to dial in nailing depth on the various shingle types you're likely to encounter.

Buy at Amazon